Arguments Against the Lottery



A lottery is a game in which people buy tickets and hope to win a prize. It is usually played for a large sum of money and can involve several different kinds of games, such as poker or keno.

There are many reasons why a state may choose to run a lottery. They are a popular way to raise tax revenues and to fund public projects. However, they can also lead to problems, such as tax evasion or illegal gambling.

The most important issue is whether the government has enough resources to manage an activity that profits them without harming citizens in other ways. This question is particularly difficult to answer in an anti-tax era, as the government may have conflicting priorities.

While the lottery is a popular and profitable form of revenue generation, it has some major problems. First, lottery revenues have a high correlation with other forms of gambling. This can create financial problems for the poor and problem gamblers, as well as for the state itself. Second, the ill-defined costs associated with lottery play make it difficult to assess how much lottery revenues actually benefit a state, or for that matter, the state economy as a whole.

One of the most common arguments against a lottery is that it is unfair. This is often based on the fact that the odds of winning are extremely low, and that those who do win do so at a high cost to their personal finances.

In addition, the tax implications of winning are very serious. In some cases, half of the prize money must be paid as taxes. And the winners often go bankrupt within a few years.

Other arguments against lotteries include the fact that they are a form of gambling, which is a prohibited activity in many states, and that they can be harmful to the health of the community. There is a growing body of literature on the adverse effects of gambling, but few studies have specifically addressed lottery gambling.

A lottery consists of a group of people who all participate in a drawing and a winner is chosen by drawing a winning number from a slip of paper. It seems like a harmless game, but in reality it is a cruel and barbarous act that is rooted in outdated traditions.

The story also highlights the danger of mob mentality, which makes it easy for people to participate in acts that are wrong or unethical. This is especially true in the lottery, where no one protests or is released from participation (Jackson 312).


The short story uses foreshadowing techniques throughout the text to make it clear that the villagers’ behavior will lead to a tragic end. For example, the old black box that holds the tickets is a symbol of the antiquated tradition of the lottery. It is shabby and faded, and no longer completely black.

Another important foreshadowing technique is the use of stones to kill Tessie Hurchinson. When Tessie’s mother arrives at the village square, Bobby Martin, the eldest boy in the town, is already holding several pebbles in his pocket. These stones are later used to kill Tessie, thus symbolizing the ritualized killing that is carried out by all the villagers.